Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Happy 4th Of July Celebration Cake
Vanilla Cake Pop
Apple Crumb Cheesecake
Vanilla Cheesecake
About
Sarah's on Central
At the heart of Eureka, Missouri, nestled on South Central Avenue, lies a hidden gem known as Sarah's on Central. This cozy eatery has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, offering a delightful dining experience that combines warmth, friendliness, and savory flavors. As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I can confidently say that if you find yourself in the area, this is a must-visit destination.
The charm of Sarah's on Central goes beyond its inviting atmosphere. Guests rave about the exceptional service, with staff members like Josh, who go above and beyond to make every patron feel welcomed. The ambience, complemented by the friendly greetings and laughter, creates a vibrant and inviting setting for a leisurely breakfast, lunch, or brunch.
One of the highlights of the menu is the versatility it offers. From delectable brunch items like chicken and waffles to heartier lunch options such as fired chicken salad and juicy burgers, there is something for everyone. Customers have been singing praises about dishes like the Central Plate, featuring fluffy scrambled eggs paired with perfectly cooked breakfast potatoes and crispy bacon or sausage—a true morning delight!
For those with a penchant for sweets, the cheesecakes at Sarah's are a revelation. The Vanilla Cheesecake with its rich and creamy texture, adorned with a whipped cream topping, tempts the taste buds, while the Apple Crumb Cheesecake with cinnamon apple compote creates a delectable fusion of flavors. Remember to place your orders with a full three-day notice to indulge in these creamy delights.
Beverage options at Sarah's on Central are equally appealing. The bar menu features an array of refreshing cocktails, from classic mimosas to creative twists like the Dreaming of Summer Mimosa, which combines Malibu Rum and pineapple juice for a tropical escape. For those seeking something different, the KahnTucky Mule adds a delightful kick to your meal with the perfect blend of Bulleit Bourbon and mint.
Just listen to the customers! One diner simply stated, "What a fortunate series of events," after discovering Sarah's on a whim. Others have echoed this sentiment, expressing their eagerness to return for more of these unforgettable culinary experiences. With ample street parking, a warm atmosphere, and a menu that offers both comfort and adventure, Sarah's on Central deserves a top spot on your dining list. Come for the food, stay for the hospitality, and leave with a full heart and belly!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ I had a really great experience here for lunch today. In full disclosure, we had planned to eat somewhere else but that place went out of business so we just popped in here. What a fortunate series of events. The waitress was really friendly and made us laugh. I had the fired chicken salad. You can see it came with a Parmesan crisp on the top that made it pretty unique. My friend said the burger was phenomenal-juicy and cooked to order. They had a wide variety of treats that looked amazing. I didn’t have any this visit but I get what everyone is raving about. Can’t wait to go back!! ”
“ We were visiting the area and was told by the staff of an adjacent restaurant to come here. We were grateful for the suggestion as the suggesting restaurant was not very welcoming. Thankfully, we felt the warmth of the environment at Sarah's on Central as we entered the door. Our server, Josh, was very nice. The food was delicious, and we enjoyed every bite. If you are visiting the area, please visit this downtown establishment. You will not be disappointed with the food or the service. ”
“ Fantastic little Brunch/Bakery place. The food was top-notch, and the service was excellent! Central is a wonderful street in Eureka! ”
“ My wife and I came with our 1 year old boy for an early birthday lunch for myself. I got the chicken and waffles as that is my absolute favorite meal and they did not disappoint! My wife really enjoyed her meal as well. Thank you for a great meal and good atmosphere! We will be back. ”
“ Friendly greeting when I sat down in this cozy restaurant. First time at this place and I ordered the Central Plate, 2 eggs, breakfast potatoes, 2 bacon strips or 2 sausage patties and 2 slices of toast. My order came out quickly and the food was hot. I ordered my eggs scrambled and I liked how they cooked them (see the picture), similar to an omelet. Not burnt or overcooked but very fluffy. The bacon has a smoked smell and taste. Forgive me for smelling the bacon but it smelled delicious. They cooked the potatoes perfectly, browned and not burnt. Rarely do I find this but they had blackberry jam, which I strongly prefer, as an option. Big serving of delicious food for a reasonable price. There’s plenty of street parking in front of the restaurant. I felt a little overlooked when the bartender helped with rolling silverware. Definitely will come back! ”
“ Sarah’s was a fun cute spot to stop and have lunch. The food was delicious and different. Love the breakfast or brunch options all day as well as sandwiches and salads. Service was great and attentive. It’s a little pricey but delicious food. ”
“ We stopped by Sarah’s On Central in Eureka to check out why they were crowned Best Brunch in West County, and let’s just say—this spot did not disappoint. (Find the poll on the West County Social facebook group) Here’s the best part—you don’t have to wait for Saturday or Sunday to indulge in the best brunch around. They’re serving up those brunch vibes Wednesday through Sunday! Since we were working (sigh), we didn’t get to enjoy one of their famous cocktails—but if you follow their socials, you already know their mimosa flights and over-the-top Bloody Marys are next level. (I was able to get a picture of their big Bloody Mary...omg) But back to the food—because WOW. Nathan ordered the Central Benny with fresh fruit, and I went full comfort mode with the Chicken Fried Steak, drenched in sausage gravy and served with breakfast potatoes, eggs, and toast. We sipped on a virgin Bloody Mary and an iced white chocolate latte. Perfection. This place is the real deal. Go ahead and bring a friend or two, get you some brunch, order the Ballpark Bloody Mary. You deserve it—even if it’s on a random Wednesday. ”
“ Love love LOVED this place! Our 15 year old said it was “cozy & cute” which we agree! The mimosa flight amazing! .. Central Benny, the breakfast bowl, & breakfast burger were delicious! .. & the pretzel bites were also demolished. Service was also fantastic! Highly recommend! ”